In September 1990, Anna Johnson gave birth to a baby boy in California. Yet the child’s genetic mother was another woman, Crispina Calvert. Both women sought recognition as his legal mother.
In 1984, Crispina underwent a hysterectomy and could no longer carry a pregnancy, although her ovaries could still produce eggs. She and her husband, Mark Calvert, decided to pursue IVF and gestational surrogacy. In 1989, Anna, a licensed vocational nurse who had previously given birth, learned of their situation through a coworker and offered to be their surrogate.
On January 15, 1990, the three signed an agreement: Crispina would provide the egg, Mark the sperm, and the resulting embryo would be transferred to Anna’s uterus. The Calverts would raise the child, and Anna agreed to relinquish parental rights. The couple promised $10,000 in installments, with the final payment due six weeks after birth, and a $200,000 life insurance policy for Anna. The embryo transfer took place on January 19, and pregnancy was subsequently confirmed.
During the pregnancy, relations deteriorated. Mark learned that Anna had experienced several stillbirths and miscarriages that she had not disclosed before the agreement. Anna believed the couple had not adequately fulfilled their insurance promise. In June, she experienced signs of premature labor and felt the Calverts had not supported her sufficiently.
In July, Anna wrote demanding the remaining payments and warning that she would refuse to surrender the child otherwise. In August, the Calverts sued for a declaration that they were the unborn child’s legal parents. Anna filed her own action seeking recognition as his mother. The cases were consolidated.
On September 19, Anna gave birth to a boy. Blood testing excluded her as the child’s genetic mother; both sides acknowledged that Mark and Crispina were his genetic parents. While litigation continued, the parties agreed that the Calverts would temporarily care for the child and Anna could visit.
In October, the trial court ruled that the Calverts were the legal parents, Anna had no parental rights, and the surrogacy agreement was lawful and enforceable. Anna’s temporary visitation was terminated. She appealed, but the appellate court affirmed. The case eventually reached the California Supreme Court.
On May 20, 1993, the Supreme Court issued its ruling. Under California’s Uniform Parentage Act at the time, both childbirth and genetic evidence could establish maternity, but here they pointed to different women. The court therefore examined reproductive intent: the Calverts had planned from the outset to conceive and raise a child through assisted reproduction, while Anna had agreed to carry the pregnancy. The court recognized Crispina as the legal mother.
The court also held that the $10,000 compensated Anna for pregnancy and childbirth, rather than purchasing a child or parental rights, and that this agreement did not violate the relevant public policies. The Supreme Court affirmed: Mark and Crispina were the legal parents, and Anna’s parental claim failed.
Justice Kennard dissented. She argued that original reproductive intent should not alone determine maternity; the child’s best interests deserved further examination, and she favored remanding the case.
If You Were in Their Shoes…
If you were Anna Johnson, and conflict arose during pregnancy because you felt your health and rights were not adequately protected, how would you respond? Can you understand her decision to threaten to withhold the child unless the remaining payments were made? Would you do the same, or pursue legal remedies for the contractual dispute?
If you were the Calverts, finally expecting a child through assisted reproduction but facing the possibility that the gestational carrier would not surrender the baby, how would you respond? Can you understand their decision to seek recognition of their parental rights in court? Would you have done the same?
The Calverts ultimately prevailed. Beyond the ruling, however, pregnancy risks, insurance arrangements, compensation, and communication also mattered. How might the rights and interests of both gestational carriers and intended parents be better protected?
Original decision: Johnson v. Calvert, 5 Cal. 4th 84 (1993)
Main reference: Crockin, The History and Future Trends of ART Medicine and Law (2021)
Leave a Reply